Okta vs Entra ID vs Google Workspace: what total cost comparisons miss
Identity provider comparisons focus on the license. The bigger number is what it costs to make every app follow the identity provider. How to compare total cost honestly.
Thomas Bieser, Cofounder and CEO ·
Most identity provider comparisons are a license table: price per user, features per tier, what is bundled with which suite. That table matters. It is also usually the smaller number.
The cost that does not appear in the table
An identity provider is only as useful as the apps that follow it. For each app, someone has to answer three questions.
- Can people sign in through the identity provider on our plan.
- Can the identity provider create and remove the account on our plan.
- If not, who does it, and what does that cost.
None of those answers depends much on which identity provider you choose. They depend on the app. The SCIM tax is charged by the app vendor, so it follows you to any identity provider that provisions through SCIM.
A total cost model that holds up
| Line | What it includes |
|---|---|
| Identity provider licenses | Per user price for the features you need, including governance |
| App upgrades | Plan upgrades needed for SSO or SCIM, across every seat |
| Custom work | Connectors, scripts and integration projects, plus their upkeep |
| Manual lifecycle work | Admin time for every joiner, mover and leaver in apps that are not automated |
| Access reviews | Time to collect, review and evidence access in every app |
| Uncovered apps | Apps no option reaches, and the risk they carry |
When teams fill in every line, the license is often the smallest one.
What we see in practice
When we compare options for a customer, we build this table with their actual app list. For a healthcare company we worked with, the comparison came down to coverage: how many of their priority apps each option could automate on current plans, and how many would need upgrades or custom builds. The identity provider license was not what decided it. See access reviews and lifecycle automation in healthcare.
How each option tends to land
- Suite bundled identity can look cheapest when you already own the suite. Check whether the governance and lifecycle features you need are in the edition you own, and how many of your apps it provisions without upgrades.
- A dedicated identity platform like Okta brings a large catalog and strong lifecycle and governance features. Its coverage still stops where apps lack SCIM on your plan.
- Any choice leaves the same gap: apps that cannot be told to create or remove a user.
Close the gap, whichever you choose
StitchOps completes whichever identity provider you choose, whether Okta, Microsoft Entra ID or Google Workspace, for sign in, provisioning and governance in any app. Your identity provider stays the source of truth for who has access. StitchOps carries lifecycle events into apps where SCIM costs extra or does not exist, anywhere a person can log in and act. Fill in the table with the SCIM tax calculator, then compare with pricing.
Frequently asked questions
- Which identity provider is cheapest?
- On license price alone the answer depends on what you already own. On total cost, the largest line is usually not the identity provider but the upgrades, custom work and manual effort needed to make every app follow it.
- Does switching identity provider avoid the SCIM tax?
- No. The SCIM tax is charged by the app vendor. Any identity provider that provisions through SCIM needs the app to support it on your plan.
- What should a total cost comparison include?
- Identity provider licenses, app plan upgrades for SSO and SCIM, custom integration work, manual joiner, mover and leaver effort, access review effort, and the apps no option can reach.
- Where does StitchOps fit?
- StitchOps completes your identity provider, whichever you choose. It carries lifecycle events into apps where SCIM costs extra or does not exist, so more of your stack is covered without upgrades or custom builds.
Okta, Microsoft Entra ID and Google Workspace are trademarks of their owners. StitchOps works with Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Google Workspace and other identity providers. This post compares cost categories, not vendor list prices, which change often.